by Devereaux Wed Feb 25, 2015 10:11 pm
Open Tops are kool looking but have real weaknesses. They are prone to all manner of malfunctions. Even my Navies, which I had converted to basically Open Top without the ejector, have real issues. It has been hard to finish a cowboy match with them. The issue is the basic design problem of joining the barrel to the frame. The wedge is crucial for getting front shake space and is hard to keep correct.
Schofields, OTOH, are solid. In the Italian version they work really well and are fun to shoot. I rather dig the neat way they unload and load and have considered buying one and shooting a cowboy match with only one gun, reloading along the way. It would be slow, but it would be fun. And you couldn't do that with a SAA - WAY too slow.
Since you are looking at old Western guns, you might consider an 1858 Remington Cap 'n Ball, and then get the conversion cylinder from the guy in Wisconsin so you can shoot .45 Colt cartridges and it still looks like a cap 'n ball. EASY removal of cylinder - you will like it!